Complete Beginner's Guide
Never heard of CEX or DEX? Perfect. This guide starts from zero and tells you everything you need to know about crypto exchanges — especially in NYC.
Think of it as a crypto bank. A company (like Coinbase, Gemini, or Kraken) runs everything. They:
Real World Example:
Creating a Coinbase account is like opening a checking account at Chase. You trust them to hold your money safely.
Think of it as peer-to-peer crypto trading. No company runs it — it's all software. You:
Real World Example:
Using Uniswap is like trading Pokemon cards directly with someone in a park — no store involved, just you and them.
Bitcoin launched in 2009, but there was nowhere to buy it easily. Mt. Gox became the first major CEX in 2010 — it was basically a guy in Japan running a website where you could trade Bitcoin. At its peak, it handled 70% of all Bitcoin trades worldwide.
The Disaster: In 2014, hackers stole 850,000 Bitcoin (worth $450M then, would be $40+ billion today). Mt. Gox collapsed. This taught everyone that trusting one company with all your crypto was dangerous.
Ethereum launched in 2015 with a revolutionary idea: programmable money. Instead of just sending Bitcoin from A to B, you could write code (smart contracts) that automatically executes trades, holds funds, or does anything else without a middleman.
This made DEXs possible. The first DEX, EtherDelta, launched in 2016. It was clunky and hard to use, but it proved the concept: you could trade crypto without trusting a company.
Uniswap launched in 2018 and changed everything. It made DEX trading actually usable. Instead of matching buyers and sellers manually, it used "liquidity pools" — basically, pools of money that anyone could trade against instantly.
Meanwhile, governments started cracking down. New York passed the BitLicense in 2015, requiring any crypto company operating in NY to get approved. Most DEXs couldn't (or wouldn't) comply, so they started blocking NY users.
Why NY Matters: NY has the strictest crypto rules in America. What happens in NY often spreads to other states. If you can navigate NY's rules, you can navigate anywhere.
FTX was one of the world's biggest CEXs. In November 2022, it imploded overnight. The CEO, Sam Bankman-Fried, had been secretly using customer funds to gamble on risky investments. $8 billion disappeared. Millions of people lost everything.
This reignited the debate: Should you trust CEXs that can steal your money? Or use DEXs where you control everything but have no protection if you mess up?
CEXs now dominate — Coinbase, Gemini, and Kraken process 90%+ of US crypto trades. They're heavily regulated, insured, and user-friendly. Perfect for beginners and people who want safety.
DEXs are still growing, but they're mainly for advanced users who want access to obscure tokens or privacy. In NYC, most DEXs block you entirely or flag your account if you connect to a CEX later.
Create account with email/password. Upload ID and selfie (KYC = "Know Your Customer"). Takes 5-30 minutes.
Link your bank account or debit card. Transfer dollars to your CEX account instantly or in 1-3 days.
Click "Buy Bitcoin" (or whatever coin). Enter amount. Click confirm. Done — you now own crypto in your CEX wallet.
Swap between coins easily. The CEX handles everything. Your crypto sits in their wallets, not yours.
Sell crypto back to dollars. Withdraw to your bank. Simple as sending Venmo.
Download MetaMask or similar. Write down your 12-word "seed phrase" — lose this, lose everything forever. No recovery possible.
DEXs don't accept dollars. Buy ETH on a CEX first, then send it to your MetaMask wallet address.
Go to Uniswap.org (if not blocked in NY). Click "Connect Wallet." Approve the connection in MetaMask.
Select tokens to swap (e.g., ETH → USDC). Approve transaction in wallet. Pay "gas fees" (network fees) — can be $5 or $100 depending on congestion.
No customer support. Sent to wrong address? Gone. Got hacked? Gone. Clicked a scam link? Gone. You are 100% responsible.
| Aspect | CEX (Coinbase, Gemini) | DEX (Uniswap, SushiSwap) |
|---|---|---|
| Control of Funds | CEX holds your crypto for you (like a bank) | You hold your own crypto in your wallet |
| Account Setup | Email, password, ID verification required | Just need a crypto wallet — no ID, no email |
| NY Legal Status | Fully licensed by NYDFS. Legal and regulated. | Mostly unlicensed. Gray area — can lead to frozen accounts. |
| Safety & Insurance | FDIC insurance on cash deposits. Crypto often insured up to $250k. | No insurance. You lose it, it's gone forever. |
| Privacy | Requires full KYC. All trades reported to IRS. | No KYC needed. Trades are anonymous (but traceable on blockchain). |
| Fees | 0.5–2% per trade + spreads | 0.1–0.3% swap fee + gas fees ($2–$100) |
| Customer Support | 24/7 email, phone, live chat | None. Community forums only. |
| Token Selection | 50-200 coins (only NY-approved ones) | Thousands of tokens — including scams |
| Ease of Use | Simple app, like using Venmo | Technical. Easy to lose everything with one mistake. |
| Fiat On/Off Ramps | Direct bank transfers, credit cards | Can't deposit or withdraw dollars directly |
| Best For | Beginners, people who want safety | Advanced users, people who want full control |
The process where CEXs verify your identity by collecting your name, address, SSN, and photo ID. Required by law to prevent money laundering.
The cost to execute transactions on a blockchain (like Ethereum). Think of it as a toll road fee — higher traffic = higher fees. Can range from $2 to $200.
Self-executing code on a blockchain. Example: "If person A sends 1 ETH, automatically send them 100 USDC." DEXs are built entirely on smart contracts.
A collection of crypto locked in a smart contract that DEX users trade against. Instead of matching buyers and sellers, you trade with this pool instantly.
Software that holds your crypto's private keys. YOU control it, not a company. Popular ones: MetaMask, Trust Wallet, Ledger. Lose your seed phrase = lose everything.
The difference between expected trade price and actual price. On DEXs with low liquidity, you might expect to get $100 worth but only get $95.
New York's cryptocurrency business license. Requires background checks, financial audits, and consumer protection measures. Only 36 companies have it.
A scam where token creators drain all the money from a DEX liquidity pool and disappear. Common on DEXs because there's no vetting process.
New York has the strictest crypto regulations in America. Here's what that means for you:
When you visit Uniswap, dYdX, or most major DEXs from a NY IP address, you'll see: "Service not available in your region." They detect your location and block you.
Why? NY's Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) has issued multi-million dollar fines to unlicensed platforms. Most DEXs can't or won't get licensed, so they simply ban NY to avoid legal trouble.
Here's a common scenario: You use a VPN to access a DEX, swap some tokens, then send them back to your Coinbase account. Within hours, Coinbase freezes your account for "suspicious activity."
CEXs use blockchain forensics to track where your crypto came from. DEX transactions trigger red flags because they can't verify the source. You'll need to prove the funds are legitimate — and the process can take weeks or months.
In NY, operating unlicensed crypto businesses is a Class E felony. While using a DEX as a consumer isn't illegal per se, you have zero legal protection if things go wrong.
Lost money to a hack? No recourse. Sent funds to wrong address? Gone forever. Got rugged? That's on you. NY regulators will literally say: "We warned you — use licensed platforms."
CEXs automatically generate tax forms (1099s) and report to the IRS. DEXs don't report anything. You're responsible for tracking every single trade manually.
NY has some of the highest state capital gains taxes (up to 10.9%). If you don't report DEX trades and get audited, you'll face penalties, interest, and potential criminal charges. The IRS is actively pursuing crypto tax evaders.
Bottom Line:
CEXs are for 95% of people, especially beginners and NY residents.
Bottom Line:
DEXs are for advanced users who prioritize freedom over safety and convenience.
NYC teacher, first-time crypto buyer
Sarah signed up for Coinbase, verified her ID, linked her bank, and bought $500 of Bitcoin. When BTC rose 20%, she sold some and withdrew dollars back to her bank within 24 hours. She got an automatic 1099 for taxes. Simple, safe, legal.
Brooklyn developer, thought he knew what he was doing
Mike set up MetaMask, used a VPN to access Uniswap, and bought a "hot new token" for $10,000. Within 48 hours, the developers drained the liquidity pool (rug pull). His tokens became worthless. No one to call, no way to recover funds. He lost it all.
Manhattan trader, tried to have it both ways
Lisa bought ETH on Gemini, sent it to MetaMask, swapped for various tokens on Uniswap, then sent some back to Gemini. Her account was immediately frozen for "high-risk activity." It took 3 months and multiple compliance calls to unlock $50k. She couldn't access her funds during that time.
Yes, but it's rare. FTX collapsed in 2022, but reputable CEXs like Coinbase and Gemini have strong security and insurance. Your cash deposits (USD) are FDIC insured up to $250k. Many CEXs also insure crypto holdings. Always research before choosing a platform.
Because there's no vetting process. Anyone can create a token and list it on a DEX in minutes. CEXs review and approve tokens before listing them. That's why you'll find legitimate projects on CEXs but thousands of worthless scams on DEXs.
Your crypto is gone forever. No recovery possible. This is different from CEXs where you can reset your password or call support. With DEXs and self-custody wallets, you are 100% responsible. Write down your seed phrase and store it somewhere safe (not digital).
Technically yes, but it's risky. If you later connect those funds to a CEX with your real NY address, you'll likely face account freezes. You're also potentially violating the DEX's terms of service. Not recommended unless you fully understand the risks.
Unlikely in their current form. NY's BitLicense requires consumer protections that DEXs fundamentally can't provide (no company to regulate, no recourse for users). A "licensed DEX" might emerge someday, but it would essentially be a CEX with DEX-like features.
Coinbase and Gemini are the top choices. Both are fully licensed in NY, have strong security records, and offer user-friendly interfaces. Gemini is NY-based and built specifically with NY regulations in mind. Kraken also operates in NY but with a smaller token selection.
If you're new to crypto or live in NYC: Start with a CEX. Period.
Get comfortable with crypto first. Learn how it works. Then, if you want to explore DEXs for specific reasons (rare tokens, privacy, etc.), you'll at least know what you're getting into.
But in NYC? The legal and practical headaches of DEXs far outweigh the benefits for 99% of people. The freedom isn't worth the risk when NY regulators are watching.
Short answer: No. Long answer: NYDFS is doubling down on control to “protect consumers.” A “licensed DEX” pilot might launch in 2026, but it’ll be as “decentralized” as a bank app. Truth: If you want full DEX freedom, move to Florida. In NYC, stick to CEX or risk it all.
We'll help you figure out the right approach for your situation — whether that's starting simple with a CEX or understanding the DEX landscape. No sales pitch, just honest advice.
Get Free NYC Crypto Advice